Discover how creativity, curiosity, and initiative thriveâor get blockedâin traditional workplaces. This discussion explores the challenges of corporate structures, the paradox of âbreaking the rules only if youâve already succeeded,â and how decentralized systems like Autonomi empower users to take control of their own data.
Learn how apps act as interfaces to personal data, giving individuals true autonomy, and why rebellion, responsibility, and innovation go hand in hand when results matter more than titles.
Whether youâre a tech enthusiast, entrepreneur, or curious about the future of work, this conversation will inspire you to rethink how we create, collaborate, and innovate.
Sorry, but I donât like this. I watched and liked your other posts because they were explaining something. Slightly rough around the edges as they are because they were generated by AI.
This one also explains ideas but in the format of a conversation which never happened because it was generated by AI. I think that is deceptive and itâs a step too far for me.
I see what you are trying to do: get some points across in a more personable way but when that steps into generating something which pretends itâs a conversation between two actual persons a line has been crossed in my view.
Itâs not that it is not quite polished enough to believable. Itâs that it is almost good enough to be.
People absorb information in very different ways. For some, an explanatory video creates far more understanding; for others, a âliveâ discussion with questions and answers works best. What really matters is not the format or the speaker, but whether the information itself is accurate and meaningful.
From my perspective, if the content is true and useful, it makes no difference whether itâs delivered by a human or by AI. The value is in the correctness and clarity of the message, not in the biological origin of the voice presenting it.
If AI already feels indistinguishable from real people to you today, then brace yourself â the next five-year period is going to be very, very rough
I fully expect weâre all in for a very disruptive and maybe even rough time over the next 5 years because of AI whether we think AI produced content is indistinguishable from human produced content or not.
I think that what is human and is represented as human still matters. Some people donât and thatâs their choice.
I would argue it is not accurate or meaningful if it is represented to be something it isnât.
How about you let them know the status of the content though? A disclaimer at the start and end: âThis conversation was not between two real people but was AI generated because a âliveâ discussion creates more understanding than an explanatory video.â
If the origin of the content doesnât matter you wonât mind doing that. And the viewer wonât mind either and they wonât feel misled if they get half way through and realise what is going on.
Iâm not trying to start an argument and I do appreciate your ongoing efforts to get the message out there.
Thanks for the thoughtful suggestion â Iâll add a clear note at the start to make it obvious this content was AI-generated, just as you suggested. It makes perfect sense to let people know the status of the content so theyâre not misled about its origin.
And yes â for anyone wondering whether AI-generated content like this is halal: well, as long as itâs transparent and not pretending to be something itâs not, Iâd say itâs halal-ish â maybe like a hallal version of a cheeseburger with extra honesty on the side. Transparency and ethical intent go a long way!
I have to agree with @storage_guy about not wanting to even start listening to a LLM speak to itself. Maybe presented as âthis is a LLM generated voice for content I, a human, generatedâ would be fine. No one expects all voicing to be human anymore, but people respect human generated content. Some of us consider LLM generated content to be slop and while slop can be good in a few cases, mostly its not.
Thanks for the feedback, @neo â I really appreciate it.
Just to clarify, these videos are not primarily created for existing community members, but rather for a broader, potential audience that may be encountering Autonomi for the first time and needs an accessible introduction to the ideas behind the project.
That said, feedback from the community is very important, and this is exactly why Iâve reworked the video into a new format, so thereâs no ambiguity about how it was generated and the intent is clearer for everyone, including long-time community members:
Listen, learn, and get inspired whit Autonomi!
