I’d choose the app I trust more, which is not going to be one that I’ve created using English instructions to a black box and has only ever been tested by me.
If I created an app using tools (compilers etc) that are known to be reliable, consistent etc, because they are used by tens of thousands of other real programmers daily, I’d also be inclined to trust that. Because I have a good understanding of every layer and experience that shows me it works.
The first thing I do when considering an app from Google Play is look through the reviews. But then I rarely use such apps because I do not trust developers I know nothing about.
I also cannot trust tools that are proven to be stochastic and unpredictable and have who knows what embedded in them, because they are impenetrable. If people could control the training data that would help, but it still leaves them with fundamental problems that mean I never trust their output.
I see this daily in the output from web search. Mistakes are frequent and often serious.
So I’m always careful when obtaining software. I look for a number of signals first.
Most people I suspect don’t do this because they either trust blindly, don’t know any alternative or don’t think it’s worth the effort.
I think it is, and not just with software. I’m currently engaged in a project that requires me to select and employ people I never dealt with before, doing things I’ve never needed done before and know little about. To start I thought WTF, but so far so good and I’ve got a reasonable process and various ways of doing my due diligence. In fact, it is just problem solving in a different set of domains and I love that. I’m good at it, enjoy it, and love learning, so it’s fun as well as scary.
I approach everything new with a mix of excitement, skepticism, analysis and self reflection. I’m not against new tech without reason, nor Musk or anyone else. I just see things differently from many and have an understanding of why. But one thing I’m not is alone in this approach or the views that result.
One of the consequences of AI generated things - not just apps - is that doing the above becomes harder. Everything becomes untrustworthy because so much of it is now created with little effort, care, cost or consequence to those spewng it out.
I’ll never pay seriously to support that. I never bought anything from Murdoch, I shun chains, big tech and any entity I see as toxic. Instead I do without or find other sources and other ways.
I’m a discerning node. Are you!? 