Pay the producer would mean all data costs the same to put up, so not really a "double dip"£ but we still need to keep poking at this one. The thing to realise is when folks talk of getting the same data over and over again then it’s very simple to remedy in a few ways, the simplest being a safecoin address can map, but regardless (there are side effects).
The number of gets on the network will be like everyone accessing the Internet. So imagine a every 100 billion page hit’s somebody on the net get’s a penny. Some folks may have a machine that get’s like mad trying to be more popular than all the other net users together. So this gets harder as the population increases. Then you have the issue of these Get requests themselves going through relays, they will disconnect nodes transmitting like mad I would think (as they are secondary connections not routing connections).
So there is a load to think about, as ever the answer will be very simple if it works at all. I like we all try to see how we would hack/game the system, it’s what the developers do continuously so great the community does as well. Not always easy though.