I agree it’s not an ideal solution for the long term, but I think it works well for the stage that SAFE is at now.
If it is auto generated, it would be difficult to remember the secret and password.
Personally I would prefer a hardware wallet that generates this stuff and that I’d just keep plugged into the computer whenever I want to be logged in.
There’s lots of options that could be explored here and I think it has to become more user friendly eventually, perhaps letting you log in with a pin code that would unlock your secret and password without you having to type it in or something like that.